What Happens with Child Arrangements When Parents Disagree

05/11/26

When parents separate, working out how your children will be cared for is one of the biggest decisions you will make. Even parents who want the same things for their children can disagree about how to get there, and it is a situation many separated families find themselves in. There are clear steps that can help, whether you reach an agreement between yourselves or ask the court to decide.

We look at the issues parents most often disagree on, some common myths about child arrangements and what happens if you cannot agree. If you need advice on your own situation, our child arrangement solicitors can help.

Common Issues Parents Disagree On

Some disagreements are about the overall arrangement for your children, while others come down to a single decision. Many of these decisions involve parental responsibility, which is the legal rights and duties a parent has for their child. Whatever the issue, there is usually a way to resolve it, and the right approach often depends on what you disagree about.

  • Where your child lives – Parents may disagree about whether their child should live mainly with one parent or split their time between both homes.
  • Time with each parent – This can include the weekly routine, overnight stays and other contact such as phone calls.
  • Holidays and special occasions – Deciding how time is shared over school holidays, Christmas and birthdays is a frequent source of disagreement, so it helps to agree dates well in advance.
  • Holidays abroad – Everyone with parental responsibility must agree before a child is taken abroad. Many parents are unaware that doing so without permission is treated as child abduction. The exception is where a Child Arrangement Order says your child lives with you, which allows trips abroad of up to 28 days unless another court order prevents it.
  • Schooling – Choosing a school is an important decision that parents with parental responsibility should make together.
  • Medical treatment – Parents may disagree about healthcare decisions and other issues affecting their child’s welfare.
    Changing a child’s name – A proposed change of name needs the agreement of everyone with parental responsibility.
  • Moving away – One parent wanting to relocate can have a significant effect on existing arrangements.

If you cannot agree on a single decision, the court can make an order to resolve it. A Specific Issue Order is used when parents disagree on one matter, such as which school your child attends or whether they should have certain medical treatment. A Prohibited Steps Order prevents a parent from taking certain actions that may not be in your child’s best interests, such as changing their name or taking them abroad.

Myths About Child Arrangements

There are several common misconceptions about child arrangements, and knowing the reality can make it easier to understand where you stand.

Myth The Reality
The mother automatically gets the children It is for parents to decide who their children live with and how much time they spend with each parent. If the court has to decide, it acts only in your child's interests and is not biased towards either parent.
You have to go to court to make arrangements If you and the other parent agree, there is no official paperwork you need to complete.
Child maintenance and seeing your child are linked Child maintenance is a legal obligation and arrangements for spending time with your child are a separate matter. Paying maintenance does not give a right to contact and missed payments are not a reason to stop it.
Having parental responsibility means you have a right to spend time with your child  Parental responsibility does not in itself give a right to spend time with your child, although the other parent must involve you in important decisions about their life.
The parent the child lives with makes every decision Routine decisions do not always need the other parent's agreement, but major decisions such as moving abroad need written agreement from everyone with parental responsibility.
A child can choose where to live at 12 There is no set age at which a child decides. The court considers your child's wishes and feelings in light of their age and understanding.

How to Reach an Agreement Without Going to Court

It is often possible to agree arrangements for your children without going to court, and there are several things that can help.

  • Keep the focus on your children – Concentrating on your children’s needs and welfare, rather than the disagreement between you, can make it easier to find common ground.
  • Put what you agree in writing – A parenting plan records what you have agreed. It is not legally binding, but it can be referred to in court if needed.
  • Find a way to communicate that works – If speaking in person or by phone is difficult, some parents find it easier to use a communication app.
  • Try mediation – A mediator is neutral and helps you make decisions based on your child’s best interests. Sessions can take place in person or remotely, and you do not have to be in the same room as your ex-partner. Where suitable, the mediator can also speak to your child about what they want, which is known as child-inclusive mediation. Mediation is not right for every family, so it is worth weighing up the advantages and disadvantages of mediation before you start.
  • Ask solicitors to negotiate – If mediation is not suitable or does not lead to an agreement, negotiation between solicitors is often the next step. Involving a solicitor does not mean your case will go to court. Our family solicitors can negotiate on your behalf and, once an agreement is reached, help make it legally binding.

If you are worried about how much mediation might cost, you may be able to get help paying for mediation through a government voucher scheme.

Do Both Parents Have to Agree to a Child Arrangement Order?

A Child Arrangement Order can still be made if you and the other parent do not agree. Either parent can apply to the court and a judge will decide what is best for your child.

Before applying, you will usually need to attend a Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting (MIAM). This is a first meeting with a mediator to see whether mediation could work for you. If you attend and your ex-partner does not, you can still go ahead with your application.

Where you do agree, a solicitor can draft a consent order to make your arrangements legally binding, which is then sent to the court for approval.

Our ultimate guide to Child Arrangement Orders explains the different types of order and what the court considers when making a decision.

What Happens If You Cannot Agree

If it has not been possible to reach an agreement, you can ask the court to decide. Every case is different, but most families go through the following stages.

Attend a MIAM

Each parent attends their own MIAM separately and the cost depends on the mediator. It is free if either parent qualifies for legal aid, and you will not need to attend in some circumstances, such as where there has been domestic abuse.

Apply to the Court

There is a fee to apply for a court order, although you may be able to get help with court fees if you are on benefits or a low income.

 

Child Focused Courts

Child Focused Courts were previously known as Pathfinder Courts and are being rolled out nationwide over 2026 and 2027. West Yorkshire have been following this model for the last 12 months and the process starts in North Yorkshire in early 2027.

The model aims to keep the child’s voice, safety and welfare at the centre of the case. It is also designed to reduce conflict between parents and help families reach a decision sooner with less Court hearings taking place.

Information is gathered at the very start. The Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service (CAFCASS) or the Local Authority prepares a Child Impact Report, so the court has a full understanding of the child’s circumstances. Alongside this, the court takes a problem-solving approach, which means concerns about domestic abuse or the child’s welfare can be identified early.

 

Stage 1 – Application and Initial Screening

When your application is made, the court will appoint a Case Protection Officer (CPO). Their role is to monitor your case as it progresses and contact you and the other parent when needed.

Where a case is urgent, particularly if there are concerns that your child may be at risk of harm, the court can prioritise your application. It may also list an early hearing to find out more.

 

Stage 2 – Child Impact Report

Once your application has been issued, CAFCASS or the Local Authority will get in touch with all parties and any other relevant professionals or organisations to collect the information needed for the Child Impact Report. The report should be completed within 40 working days.

The report gives the court a thorough understanding of your child’s daily life, their needs and what they would like to happen. If your child is old enough, the author will arrange to talk with them. Where appropriate, this conversation usually takes place without either parent in the room.

Each report will include:

  • a photograph of your child or children
  • your child’s wishes
  • details about your family
  • input from any professionals who work with your family
  • their recommendations on the way forward

 

Stage 3 – Gatekeeping

When the court receives the Child Impact Report, your case will be passed to a judge or legal adviser to look at on paper. You won’t need to attend Court that day. The Judge or legal adviser will consider all of the information in the report and decide whether:

  • a decision hearing can be listed straight away
  • an independent domestic violence adviser or domestic abuse support worker should be involved
  • any further information is needed before the decision hearing

 

Stage 4 – Decision Hearing

The Decision hearing normally takes place 2-3 weeks after the Gatekeeping process. Your case will be heard by a District Judge or Magistrates. They will look at the Child Impact Report and your child’s welfare before deciding which order to make. They will also consider how their decision should be communicated to your child.

Occasionally, a decision cannot be made at this hearing and in these circumstances the court will list a final hearing, and you may be required to give evidence.

What Family Courts Expect from Parents

Family courts expect parents to try to resolve disagreements themselves where it is safe to do so, and the court process encourages agreement at every stage. That does not mean you should avoid going to court if you need to. The court will want to see that you have considered other options first and that your focus is on your child rather than the disagreement between you.

If You Are Worried About Your Child's Safety

Some disagreements involve concerns about a child’s safety or domestic violence between parents, and in these situations mediation may not be suitable. If you have been a victim of domestic abuse, you may be entitled to legal aid to help with the cost of proceedings.

Legal aid is subject to an assessment of your income. It is available to people who receive certain benefits or who are on a low income and have minimal savings or assets. We can assess whether you are eligible and, if you are not, talk you through your other options.

If this applies to you, please contact us to arrange a legal aid assessment or to speak to us in confidence.

Speak to Our Child Arrangement Solicitors

Disagreeing with the other parent about your children can be stressful, and getting the right advice early can make a real difference. Our team helps parents reach agreements through negotiation and mediation, and if court proceedings become necessary, we can represent you throughout. We can also help change or enforce an existing order if your circumstances change.

We have offices in Leeds, York and Harrogate and offer a free 15 minute consultation. Call us on 0113 246 8163 or contact us for confidential advice about arrangements for your children.